All Grown Up appears in the March issue of Marie Claire's "What We're Reading" list. ("Bravo to Attenberg, who, with hilarity and honesty, tells the story of an adult woman who wants what she wants, not what she's supposed to want.") It also makes an appearance on Tablet's Seven Jewish Literary Fiction Books To Read This Year list, Autostraddle's 45 Queer and Feminist Books You Need to Read in Early 2017 list, and Bustle's 15 Most Anticipated Feminist Book Releases of 2017 list.